Обсуждение турнира | Tournament Discussion

[Scooter]

Hi , sorry Sherl , i'm not understand General rules " In next stage will proceed best 4 players from each group." So what they do in the next round KooolPhil , Vzeroshenui , dontlookatme , HitGirl or Aizenkur , XeJljl , cheremis , Anestis and Veanson Six in their group.It follows that we play 10 games to eliminate one player, just plain wrong ...

[Vaenson]

Ye, while it was great fun to play in this tournament i couldnt achive to get under the best 4. So its meaningless to play the other 4 best of the other groups to proove again that im not worth to be under the best 4 .

Anyway..Gl all with this tournament was great fun with alot quality games...
@ sherl

[cheremis]

just plain wrong

why you did not raise this issue in the first round?

[Sherl]

Hi , sorry Sherl , i'm not understand General rules " In next stage will proceed best 4 players from each group." So what they do in the next round KooolPhil , Vzeroshenui , dontlookatme , HitGirl or Aizenkur , XeJljl , cheremis , Anestis and Veanson Six in their group.It follows that we play 10 games to eliminate one player, just plain wrong ...

For the next round in each group should be 6 players.
To do this, go to the next round at the best 4 players and a few players from the 5th and 6th places, who scored the most points.
Also, I think it is wrong that in some groups the players go from 4th place with 2-3 points, while others can not do it with 7 or more.
Therefore, they are given one last chance.

But 3rd stage - this is the last group stage. To the playoffs will get on 3 best player from each group (3*10 group=30) + 2 best players with 4th places from all group, becouse for the playoffs need 32 players.

In the evening, I will sum up the 2nd group stage and everything will be clear.

[RTKAbu]

Just a question, i love the tournament, and the rules are pretty good, but cant we limit eles to max 1. Although the tourney is very enjoyable, its an ele camel fest all over. I think everyone i played used the ele fear combo, including me. Its very predictable, and i think eles are just a bit to OP in the morale sense (so the damage is of, but the fear it gives which stacks). Just a suggestion though.

[Sherl]

Camel fear only horse.
Elephants included in limit melee cav.

I think rules ok now.

[Sherl]

I think to the period of the play-offs must be replaced faction on groups:

1-th group: very strong - Egypt,
2-th group: strong - Seleucids, Macedon, Arverni, Iceni, Suebi, Rome
3-th group: moderate - Epirus, Pontus, Carthage, Parthia, Sparta, Athens

4-th group - weak - non

Your opinion?

Думаю на плей-офф надо провести корректировку фракций вот таким образом:

1-th group: very strong - Egypt,
2-th group: strong - Seleucids, Macedon, Arverni, Iceni, Suebi, Rome
3-th group: moderate - Epirus, Pontus, Carthage, Parthia, Sparta, Athens

4-th group - weak - non

Ваши мнения?

[Kwint]

Думаю, стоит македонию на уровень ниже опустить. Не вижу, чем эпир хуже македонии.

[cheremis]

По мне Селевкиды сильней всех варваров и Рима . А Македония согласен - похожа на Эпир (только у маков мечи но у Эпира слоны) . Хотя можно и так на пробу сыграть (разницы не много - от людей зависит что им брать) .

[Klayton]

Думаю на плей-офф надо провести корректировку фракций вот таким образом:

1-th group: very strong - Egypt,
2-th group: strong - Seleucids, Macedon, Arverni, Iceni, Suebi, Rome
3-th group: moderate - Epirus, Pontus, Carthage, Parthia, Sparta, Athens

Ваши мнения?

может оставить всё как есть ? и доиграть турнир с изначальными правилами?

имхо